The Person We Understand Ourselves to Be

Most of us have a fairly settled understanding of what kind of person we are. We describe ourselves as independent, generous, responsible, patient, ambitious, easygoing, or practical. We know our strengths, recognize some of our weaknesses, and have explanations for why we behave as we do. These descriptions seem reasonable, and we can usually find plenty of evidence to support them.

But how closely do they correspond to the way we actually live?

Someone who considers himself generous may readily help friends and family, yet become resentful when people ask for more than he wants to give. Someone who prides herself on being independent may depend heavily on the approval of others. A person who describes himself as easygoing may become controlling whenever things don’t go his way. We tend to regard these occasions as exceptions, explaining them through fatigue, pressure, difficult people, or unusual circumstances.

Sometimes those explanations are accurate. But they can also protect an understanding of ourselves that we have little interest in questioning.

Consider someone who has always thought of himself as patient. He’s considerate toward colleagues, willing to help people work through difficulties, and generally tolerant of mistakes. His friends would probably describe him that way too. Yet he becomes irritated when people move too slowly, repeat themselves, or fail to understand something he considers obvious. He doesn’t think of this as impatience. He thinks of it as frustration with people who should know better. The distinction allows him to preserve a quality he considers part of his character.

The same process can operate in the opposite direction. Someone who considers herself socially awkward may continue describing herself that way despite having developed close friendships and becoming comfortable in situations she once avoided. A person who thinks he’s incapable of leadership may dismiss occasions when others have relied on his judgment. Someone who believes she isn’t creative may never seriously consider activities that would challenge that conclusion.

Unfavorable descriptions can be just as resistant to evidence as favorable ones. We may explain away accomplishments as luck, dismiss compliments as politeness, or treat an occasional failure as confirmation of something we’ve believed for years.

Other descriptions seem neither particularly favorable nor unfavorable. We may consider ourselves solitary, practical, cautious, or uninterested in certain activities. These may be accurate observations about our preferences and tendencies, but they can also become assumptions we rarely reconsider. We stop asking whether we might enjoy something different because we’ve already decided what kind of person we are.

The qualities we attribute to ourselves also vary with circumstances. A person may be confident at work and uncertain in intimate relationships, generous with friends and guarded with family, decisive when solving someone else’s problems and hesitant when confronting his own. These differences aren’t always contradictions. Confidence in a familiar professional setting doesn’t guarantee confidence in an unfamiliar social situation. Patience when we have plenty of time tells us little about our patience when we’re exhausted or under pressure.

A description may be accurate within certain conditions and misleading when treated as a general statement about character. Yet we rarely describe ourselves by explaining all the circumstances under which our qualities do and don’t appear. We say, “I’m a patient person,” without considering how much that statement leaves out.

Our understanding of ourselves is also influenced by the difference between what we intend and what other people experience. Someone who sees himself as helpful may be experienced by others as intrusive. Someone who considers herself direct may be regarded as unnecessarily harsh. A person who believes he’s keeping the peace may be avoiding conversations that other people need to have.

We know our intentions, remember the circumstances that influenced our decisions, and can explain why we behaved as we did. Other people encounter our conduct without necessarily knowing what lies behind it. Their judgments can be mistaken, but so can ours. Neither perspective provides a complete account, and the differences between them can reveal aspects of ourselves that our familiar descriptions leave out.

Some descriptions become particularly difficult to question because of what we’ve invested in them. Being responsible, intelligent, independent, or dependable may be something we take pride in, something other people admire, or something that distinguishes us from people we don’t want to resemble. An unfavorable description may carry a different kind of authority simply because we’ve believed it for so long. In either case, contradictory evidence challenges more than an isolated opinion. It challenges an established understanding of who we are.

People do have recognizable qualities, habits, abilities, and tendencies. Some remain consistent across many circumstances. But our understanding of ourselves is necessarily selective. We remember certain experiences, emphasize particular qualities, explain away some behaviors, and overlook others. We also inherit descriptions from people who have known us, sometimes accepting their judgments without examining whether they remain accurate.

We can spend years describing ourselves in ways that seem perfectly reasonable, supported by memories, explanations, and the opinions of people who know us. The resulting picture may be coherent and convincing while still leaving out important parts of who we are.

The descriptions aren’t the person. They’re conclusions we’ve reached about the person.

And conclusions can be wrong.

Related Essays

DOTT

One last thing... Let's verify your subscription.

We use double opt-in. That means you need to confirm your subscription before we can send you anything.

Check your inbox for a confirmation email to complete your subscription.

Didn’t see it? Be sure to check your spam or promotions folder.

Contact Us

Disclaimer

This website does not provide medical advice. The information provided is for educational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, it’s not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your physician or qualified health care provider with any questions about a medical condition or treatment and before starting a new health regimen. Never disregard or delay seeking professional medical advice because of something you read on this website.